Project

General

Profile

Actions

Feature #2436

open

Structuring places

Added by Alexander Watzinger about 1 year ago. Updated about 1 month ago.

Status:
Acknowledged
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
-
Category:
Backend
Target version:
Start date:
2025-01-27
Estimated time:

Description

Like discussed in the meeting and the meeting with Welterbe:

A hierarchy for places would help a lot to structure place data, e.g. a forest exists which overlaps multiple other places and the places should be still places and not features of the forest. The question is how to deal with that.

One possibility would be to allow multiple places as super for one sub.
This should be possible from the technical and model perspective but we should think carefully about the implications and if they are worth these additions.

Some thoughts about that, e.g. if we allow this "freely", e.g. over places, features, stratigraphic units, artifacts and human remains:
  • It won't be possible anymore to show this as a hierarchical visual presentation if there are multiple supers, especially if they are not on the same level.
  • There would always be the danger of recursive connections. Of course we can try to intercept them but at e.g. imports this can get really complicated and error prone.
  • If we want to implement checks that the geolocations of subs are really in the regions of their supers, this would get more complicate too
  • ...

Update November 2025
Current approach would be to implement that places can be subs of other places. Although this won't solve overlapping multiple places it would still be very helpful with structuring places.


Related issues 3 (3 open0 closed)

Related to OpenAtlas - Feature #1916: Re-arrange place structureAcknowledged2022-12-19Actions
Related to OpenAtlas - Feature #2687: Multiple super for placeAcknowledged2025-11-23Actions
Follows OpenAtlas - Feature #2464: OpenAtlas major version 9.0.0In ProgressAlexander Watzinger2025-01-24Actions
Actions #2

Updated by Alexander Watzinger 7 months ago

  • Target version changed from Wishlist to 9.2.0
Actions #3

Updated by Alexander Watzinger 6 months ago

  • Start date changed from 2024-12-20 to 2025-01-27
  • Follows Feature #2464: OpenAtlas major version 9.0.0 added
Actions #4

Updated by Alexander Watzinger about 1 month ago

Actions #5

Updated by Alexander Watzinger about 1 month ago

  • Description updated (diff)
  • Subject changed from Multiple supers for place subs to Structuring places

We merged similar issues to this one. Current approach would be to implement that places can be subs of other places.
I also added it to the next developer meeting agenda.

Actions #6

Updated by Alexander Watzinger about 1 month ago

Actions #7

Updated by Alexander Watzinger about 1 month ago

  • Target version changed from 9.2.0 to 9.1.0
Actions

Also available in: Atom PDF